[Dev] Revisiting the Foundation Tile Size
Nov 13, 2026
Previously, we compared several foundation tile sizes for BARIEL, including 2×2m, 3×3m, 4×4m, and 8×8m.
At the time, we decided to first implement 8×8m, since it provided the most room for movement, trap placement, dodging, and aerial action.
We also agreed that we would revisit the size after testing it in actual gameplay.
Now that development has progressed, that time has come.
8×8m Was Not the Wrong Choice
As a combat space, 8×8m still has clear advantages.
Movement feels comfortable, there is enough room to fight between traps, and the space does not feel too restrictive during dodging or direct combat.
It still satisfies one of the most important conditions from our original discussion:
there needs to be enough room for action combat.
The problem became more noticeable as development continued and more traps and building parts were added.
More Space Also Means Bigger Buildings
When a single foundation tile is 8×8m, even a small number of tiles can make the overall structure quite large.
At first, the extra space felt useful.
But as the number of traps increased and we started building actual defensive layouts, we also started seeing more unused space.
This became especially noticeable when trying to narrow monster paths and guide them toward specific traps.
To create the routes we wanted, we often needed more barricades than necessary.
And because the structures themselves were so large, some traps and spaces ended up being used less efficiently.
The space worked well for combat, but we started asking ourselves:
Was it actually too large for building effective defensive layouts?
That led us back to the foundation size discussion.
Starting Again from 1 Meter
This time, we went back and compared a wider range of options:
1×1m, 2×2m, 3×3m, 4×4m, 5×5m, and 6×6m.
One condition from the original discussion remained unchanged.
The building system should not reduce the space needed for BARIEL’s action combat.
The player still needs enough room to move between traps, avoid attacks, and directly engage enemies.
At the same time, smaller tiles are not automatically better.
BARIEL is not only about building defenses.
Players also need to explore the world and fight outside the territory.
If each foundation tile becomes too small, creating the same defensive structure would require placing many more pieces, which naturally increases the amount of time spent building.
More precise construction could come at the cost of slowing down the overall flow of play.
Once again, the problem became finding the right balance between combat space and building efficiency.
This Time, We Are Trying 6×6m
For now, we decided to test 6×6m.
Our expectation is that it will allow us to build denser defensive structures than 8×8m, while still leaving enough space for the player to fight directly between traps.
Of course, we are not treating 6×6m as the final answer either.
We still need to build with it, place traps, create monster paths, and fight inside those spaces before we can properly judge it.
As before, actual gameplay matters more than a number that looks good on paper.
Making the Next Change Less Painful
There is another thing we are paying close attention to during this change.
If we ever need to change the foundation size again, we want the next adjustment to require much less work.
At this point, several building elements and traps have already been implemented around the 8×8m standard.
Changing to 6×6m is not as simple as replacing one number.
We need to review the structures affected by the scale change, adjust placement rules, and test whether everything still works correctly in actual gameplay.
So while making this change, we are also documenting which systems are affected by the foundation size and what needs to be updated.
Where possible, we are restructuring things so that future size changes will be easier to handle.
This time, we are changing from 8×8m to 6×6m.
There is no guarantee that we will never revisit the decision again.
So instead of focusing only on never having to change it again, we are also trying to make sure that if we do need to change it again, it will be easier next time.
Back to Playtesting
When we first chose 8×8m, we never considered it a permanent decision.
The plan was always to start with the roomiest option and scale it down based on actual gameplay.
And now we are following through on that plan.
8×8m gave us plenty of room for movement and action, but as the amount of content increased, new problems started to appear in building and defense.
This time, we are trying 6×6m.
We will build with it, place traps, block monster paths, and test combat again.
The size of a single foundation tile in BARIEL is still a work in progress.