[Dev] Where Building Meets Combat
Aug 7, 2026
While implementing the building system, there was one topic we ended up discussing for much longer than expected:
How large should a single foundation tile be?
The main candidates were 2×2m, 3×3m, 4×4m, and 8×8m.
At first, it seemed like we just needed to pick a reasonable size and move on.
But in BARIEL, the floor is not simply a surface for placing structures. It is also the space where traps are deployed and where the player and monsters actually fight.
That made the strengths and weaknesses of each size much more obvious.
2×2m
This was the most familiar option.
It is a common size in many building games, and because the unit is small, it allows for detailed construction and more precise layouts.
However, in BARIEL, we also had to consider trap placement and combat movement.
If the foundation unit is too small, building becomes more precise, but the placement grid can become overly fragmented and the overall layout more complicated during actual play.
3×3m
On its own, the size did not seem bad.
What kept bothering us was the fact that it was an odd-numbered unit.
As we add doors, traps, corridors, and other structures, we may frequently need to align centers or divide spaces into halves.
It might not cause problems immediately, but as the number of structures increases, it could make development and placement logic more awkward.
4×4m
At first, this seemed like the safest option.
The size felt reasonable, and being an even-numbered unit also made it easy to divide and organize structures.
But once we looked at it from an actual combat perspective, things became less clear.
The player character in BARIEL is roughly 2 meters tall, and the dodge roll covers about 4 meters.
If a trap is placed in the middle of a 4-meter-wide space, it could block the player’s roll path or make the combat area feel too cramped.
And traps in BARIEL are not simply tools for dealing damage.
Some traps launch monsters into the air, allowing the player to follow up, stick to airborne enemies, and continue with aerial combos.
When we considered that style of play, 4×4m felt clean as a building unit, but potentially too restrictive as a combat space.
8×8m
On the other hand, 8×8m looked too large at first.
For a single foundation tile, it is a fairly generous size.
But when we considered movement, trap placement, dodging, and aerial combat together, it gave us the most breathing room.
So for now, we decided to implement the foundation tiles at 8×8m.
That does not mean this is the final size.
We plan to actually build with the tiles, place traps, test dodge rolls and aerial combos, and then evaluate the scale again.
On paper, 8 meters may sound large, but it can feel completely different once it is placed inside the game.
If necessary, we may later reduce the size to 4×4m or even smaller.
In the End, We Decided to Play It
One interesting thing about this discussion was that no option was clearly wrong.
2×2m was better for detailed construction.
4×4m was structurally clean.
8×8m provided more room for combat.
Everyone was simply looking at the problem from a different angle.
From a building perspective, smaller units are useful.
From a development perspective, even-numbered units are easier to work with.
And once combat and action are included, the game needs more space.
So rather than deciding on the final number in a meeting, we chose to start with the roomiest option, implement it, and then scale it down based on actual gameplay.
When making a game, even a number that looks simple on paper can end up being closely tied to how the game feels to play.
That is how even a single floor tile in BARIEL is being decided.